I have an oddball question for you. I recently came across an original
boxed set of the 1923-24 Walter Mails Game with instructions, rules card and
player cards. What I am wondering is that the package (and the contents as
pictured) lists 55 players compared the 56 in the SCD catalog. Can you give
me a little info in whether the red backs might have been the initial set
produced since there are less players than the Blue backs that I have seen
on-line. You do mention that the player info differs from red to blue, but
I want to make sure before I grade these and have someone state that the set
is missing one. Take a look at the scans and let me know your thoughts.
Thanks.
As far as we can tell, both have 56. Justin Moen, my partner in crime back in Iola, says:
From what I’ve seen, there are indeed 56 players in this set and, unless new
evidence suggests otherwise, the blue backs were issued first and in less
quantities as opposed to the red backs. And many variations of player
personal data between red and blue backs have been reported.
But of course we would like confirmation (or rebuttal) from the people who collect these cards or have knowledge dealing with them. Thanks!

I have a handful of cards from this set and am looking to collect one of each if that’s possible. I can confirm the existence of the following:
BLUE
Buzz Arlett
Jim Bagby
Hugh Critz
Jake Daubert
Lew Fonseca
Ed Gharity (Gharitty)
George Groves
Harry Krause
Stuffy McInnis
Pat J. Moran
Jimmy O’Connell
Babe Pinelli
Elmer Ponder
Joe Sewell
Pat Shea
Suds Sutherland
George Uhle
RED
Dave Bancroft
Johnny Bassler (Basseler)
Rube Benton
George Burns
Ed Gharity (Gharitty)
Ray Kremer
Stuffy McInnis
Hack Miller
Guy Morton
Edwin Rommell
Walter Schmidt
Wilford Shupe
Jack Smith
Bill Skiff
James Tierny
Bruce Brown
Columbia, MD